Jump to:
Housing, Transportation, and Climate
Candidates proceeding to the municipal election on November 2nd are indicated with †
Evandro Carvalho †
pdf of answers
William Dickerson
(no answers submitted)
Nikkia Jean-Charles
(no answers submitted)
Deeqo Jibril
(no answers submitted)
Leonard Lee
pdf of answers
Joel Richards
(no answers submitted)
Troy Smith
pdf of answers
Jacob Urena
(no answers submitted)
Josette Williams
pdf of answers
Brian Worrell †
(no answers submitted)
Click on a question to read each candidate's answer.
Housing, Transportation, and Climate
Evandro Carvalho
Yes, we need both more affordable housing and that it be built in ways that have net zero emissions and programs be done to retrofit existing housing to conserve energy.
Transportation is key for people to get to work, but we need to increase the use of buses (including dedicated bus lanes on major neighborhood streets), bike lanes, and the MBTA subways. We need to get buses with the least emissions damage.
Doing our share for climate means defining it as being something that all city policies should have to indicate how they are contributing to meeting the city's climate goals.
Leonard Lee
I see these issues through the lens of equity. They are all connected because together they contribute to quality of life for all residents. I will support and fight for policies that connect these issues and improve living conditions. For example, smart development connects housing to transportation hubs which in turn lessens gas emissions.
Troy Smith
Housing, Transportation and Climate are major issues which require a team effort in re-educating those who are unaware of the immediate effects to quality of life for all. Housing must be affordable and equitable for all regardless of race, sexual orientation and financial limitations. Transportation has to be accessible for all citizens and must be affordable to the point those who are living below poverty are able to make it to their respective jobs. Climate is greatly effected by eliminating our green spaces which acts a natural filter.
Josette Williams
All are inextricably linked.Transportation is a major factor in job access; reliable/affordable transportation between quality homes and work is essential. Solutions must include climate justice. Transportation must include dedicated bus lanes/free transit/regulating traffic flow/city-wide cycling infrastructure/improved pedestrian safety.Include additional greenspace, particularly in D4 which has been a sacrifice zone, in roadway improvements. Locate housing programs, including on vacant lots, near public transportation. Promote policy within CH focused on the voice of advocacy groups.
What is your mobility/housing story?
Evandro Carvalho
Car
Subway
Commuter rail
Bus
Bike (bike-share or personal bicycle)
Mobility device
Walking
Rideshare
Moped/motorcycle
Scooter
Carpool
Other
Leonard Lee
Car
Subway
Commuter rail
Bus
Bike (bike-share or personal bicycle)
Mobility device
Walking
Rideshare
Moped/motorcycle
Scooter
Carpool
Other
Troy Smith
Car
Subway
Commuter rail
Bus
Bike (bike-share or personal bicycle)
Mobility device
Walking
Rideshare
Moped/motorcycle
Scooter
Carpool
Other
Josette Williams
Car
Subway
Commuter rail
Bus
Bike (bike-share or personal bicycle)
Mobility device
Walking
Rideshare
Moped/motorcycle
Scooter
Carpool
Other
Evandro Carvalho
Duplex/Triple-decker
4-to-6-unit building
Over-six-unit apartment building
As a renter
As a landlord
Home ownership
Housing insecure
Single-family home
Public housing / Section 8
Deed-restricted affordable
Urban
Suburban
Rural
Other
Leonard Lee
Duplex/Triple-decker
4-to-6-unit building
Over-six-unit apartment building
As a renter
As a landlord
Home ownership
Housing insecure
Single-family home
Public housing / Section 8
Deed-restricted affordable
Urban
Suburban
Rural
Other
Troy Smith
Duplex/Triple-decker
4-to-6-unit building
Over-six-unit apartment building
As a renter
As a landlord
Home ownership
Housing insecure
Single-family home
Public housing / Section 8
Deed-restricted affordable
Urban
Suburban
Rural
Other
Josette Williams
Duplex/Triple-decker
4-to-6-unit building
Over-six-unit apartment building
As a renter
As a landlord
Home ownership
Housing insecure
Single-family home
Public housing / Section 8
Deed-restricted affordable
Urban
Suburban
Rural
Other
Policy Proposals
Evandro Carvalho
By installing dedicated bus lanes on major neighborhood streets wide enough to do this. By constructing turn arounds for buses on roads to enable this and meeting schedules better.
By using city seats on the MBTA Advisory Board to influence MBTA policies.
Leonard Lee
I would use federal stimulus dollars to increase bus service to neighborhoods that are most in need. I support the $15 million in House appropriations for the Roxbury multimodal project which Rep. Ayanna Pressley recently secured. If approved by the Senate and signed into law by Pres. Biden, the project will improve the layout of sidewalks, bike-lanes, vehicle traffic and bus lanes. This can serve as a model.
Troy Smith
All major road construction would be performed off peak hours and if needed during the night time hours providing greater accessibility to make the necessary repairs to keep overall traffic and operation of buses flows freely.
Josette Williams
- Dedicated bus lanes
- Free bus service
- Delivery truck set asides
- Late night T service
- Tax on call rides
- Painted or clearly defined cross walks
- As appropriate, off peak truck delivery
- Restrict truck routes
Evandro Carvalho
I would work with other City Councilors and the Mayor to meet with the Secretary of Transportation, the General Manager of the MBTA on this governance issue and Boston representation. I will ask our Boston legislative delegation to be active in this effort with us.
Leonard Lee
Yes. I would join my fellow councillors in fighting for a seat on the board. I would strongly advocate for a renewal of the Board.
Troy Smith
Yes, every organization performs greater with a body of governance which will assist as well as hold accountable. I would advocate for a new board of governance and a seat to ensure the City of Boston is well informed and the concerns of the City are heard and addressed.
Josette Williams
It is very surprising that the FMCB is sunsetting and as of now the Governor has indicated he will not extend it. I would advocate as a City Councillor to “bully pulpit” for its reestablishment or a similar body. The City must have representation. I would also push for a City Council resolution that the City appoint a representative to attend every public meeting of the MBTA advocating for the city's needs. I would also push for state legislation expanding the T Board to include representatives from the major communities served by the T.
Evandro Carvalho
By working with other City Councilors to hold the Mayor and Transportation Department accountable through hearings and if necessary holding up approval of the annual city budget.
Leonard Lee
I would set deadlines that are tied to the funding of these projects.
Troy Smith
Review the plans in greater detail taking notes as to what has changed and what needs to be changed to implement both short and long term project goals to ensure completion before or on January 1, 2030.
Josette Williams
The Go Boston 2030 plan was an extraordinary effort which included many constituencies.The 4 strategic categories are specifically set forth in the plan and would be transformative for District 4 and the City as a whole. The key to implementation is funding, community engagement and oversight of progress. We must continue to lobby for the funding from the State and federal governments. As the infrastructure proposals work their way through Congress ,we need to be sure that Boston gets an appropriate allocation to keep moving forward. In the meantime, there are many short term, not terribly costly, projects that could have a terrific return in terms of safety and livability. We have seen in parts of the City that crosswalk improvements, restripping of roadways, adding dedicated bicycle lanes etc can be accomplished. I will advocate for their inclusion in the City budgeting process.
Evandro Carvalho
Through organizing neighborhood meetings of residents and small businesses to talk through these plans along with the City’s Transportation Department to find consensus but give priority to climate and transit friendly policies.
Leonard Lee
The Covid-19 pandemic has changed the nature of parking in business districts and encouraged some residents to walk or bike instead of taking the subway or bus. I would work with community based businesses and neighborhood groups to build support for spaces where people can walk or bike.
Troy Smith
I encourage Transportation Dept. to conduct as many Community meetings in advance of actual start dates to answer questions and address concerns and fears. Especially when major changes are about to drastically effect what people have always lived in a certain manner and now must adjust to new ways of living.
Josette Williams
Improving walking and biking safety in the city is essential and might well require a reduction in parking spaces. However, small businesses, the life blood of the city, may require spaces for delivery of supplies and parking for take out and customers. A balance is needed and most likely achieved by bringing together the two “groups” and hearing others’ points of view. We have seen during COVID that restaurants have taken over sections of streets and it has worked well. We have, as a result, a new way of thinking about shared space.
Evandro Carvalho
I think we need to study increasing the affordability percentages at least in some areas since Somerville and Cambridge are now at 20%. I think both choices are great choices. Though in the 12 unit building, we get a higher percentage of affordable units, the 60 unit building we get more affordable units built. My support would also depend on the voice and input of the abbutters, the neighborhood, and the general character of the community. I would also push more and more for homeownership, as that is one of key ways for us to eliminate the wealth gap.
Leonard Lee
There is an affordable housing crisis in Boston and other major cities . I support a rate of 33% to make the project financially feasible and provide access to more affordable units.
Troy Smith
I am 100% in support of a 12 unit building with 50% affordable units. My reasoning is we in the City of Boston have allowed developers too much growth with yet too many people homeless or about to evicted is speaking to the fact there is not enough affordable and income restricted housing within the our City. I do not want Boston to have all of these high risers vacant be in the Seaport or District Neighborhoods as a result of families not being able to meet the financial demands to pay rent or eat.
Josette Williams
In the abstract, the math dictates choosing the 60 unit project. But many other considerations must be taken into account. Location; proximity to transportation; number of other large scale projects in the area; character of neighborhood.
The broader question is what is the right percentage that adds more affordable housing but doesn’t turn away developers. I have previously taken the position that the percentage be doubled and look again at the applicability to projects with fewer than 10 units. In addition, we should reconsider the developer’s ability to buy out the obligation or place the required units off site.
Evandro Carvalho
I would work to create a task force of people from appropriate city departments, non-profit developers, for profit developers, contractors, unions, civic association, other city councilors to examine current practices and what can be done to reform them so there’s a better process and time scale for these decisions.
Leonard Lee
I support Governor Baker's plan to pump millions of state and federal stimulus dollars to build new owner occupied homes for below-market rate sales in Boston.
Troy Smith
Encourage Neighborhood organizations to purchase the land within their respective neighborhoods. Create a comprehensive first time home buyers program and provide selected mortgage lenders and banks and local contractors to build the homes as agreed designs have been preapproved. Create a system that is one stop, shop and local for each neighborhood.
Josette Williams
The City must streamline the process and give housing a priority in getting through city agencies. Perhaps a one stop housing office that would draw from the constituent departments would be helpful. Further the zoning code must be amended to speed up the process by creating as of right projects or those with limited review, based upon an updated zoning code that sets out community accepted standards.
Evandro Carvalho
Increasing percent of affordability under the IDP policy. Increase funding for outreach to tenants on their rights. Fund Greater Boston Legal Services so more tenants can be represented in court to prevent evictions.
Fund tenants groups like City Life, Chinese Progressive Association to enable more tenants to get organized so they can negotiate on rent increases.
Increase funding for the city’s rent subsidy program utilizing the major American Rescue Plan Act funding the city is getting.
Leonard Lee
I support the City of Boston Emergency Rental and Mortgage Program and the Rental Relief Fund. I also support the Housing Stability Notification Act.
Troy Smith
No answer
Josette Williams
Unfortunately, the City is under the thumb of the Legislature in many unnecessary areas. Housing displacement protection is one area. The BHA has created a project based housing voucher program funded by the City. We recommend expansion of the program as well as the Tenant Based Voucher Program. Home Base, a non profit organization, now partners with the BHA to reduce evictions to maintain tenant stability. I would explore expanding that relationship. In addition, the City can work with landlords to pressure tham o accommodate tenants in crisis and perhaps use the power of the City if necessary- the carrot and stick approach. An effort could be made to get state legislation under a home rule petition to broaden the city's authority.
Evandro Carvalho
I would try to bring together residents, civic associations, non-profit and for profit developers, city department representatives in a task force to examine these important issues and make recommendations for changes in policies and ordinances.
Leonard Lee
I would advocate for alternatives to parking spaces such as bike racks and rental cars such as Zipcar.
Troy Smith
I am firm in belief the more information shared with residents, along with precise plans of construction with graphics and transparency will gain community support greater than an elected official just endorsing the project. Developers must convince all stakeholders the benefit beyond the Contractors financial gain.
Josette Williams
Each project is unique and impacts its community in unique ways. One size does not fit all. Each element, housing, parking, open space, and environment must be considered. The highest preference is to housing, but it must be balanced with the other elements. Parking is essential for access to jobs if the project is not near quality public transportation. Green space is essential to quality of life, and community peace and safety.
As for opposition, different people have different points of view and are impacted differently. A key to finding a balance among priorities is to provide opportunities for people to hear and listen to different points of view. Balance often means compromise. At some point the permit granting authority must be the final arbiter after a decent respectful exchange.
Additional Questions
Each candidate has chosen an answer among these options; click on any button with shadow (like the Somewhat Support button below) to read the candidate's additional explanation:
Strongly Support
Somewhat Support
candidate's explanation
Neither Support nor Oppose
Somewhat Oppose
Strongly Oppose
Evandro Carvalho
Somewhat Support
I have read the most recent Boston Vision Progress Report and I agree, the City needs to update it’s Vision Zero Action Plan, as it hasn't been updated since 2018. Our traffic patterns are changing. I'll work with our transportation department to ensure we update this plan sooner rather than later.
Leonard Lee
Somewhat Support
The city must come up with alternative strategies and solutions to improve safety. Speed management, Public transit, walking and biking can help. As a city councillor I will push for the city to develop a safe street strategy.
Troy Smith
Neither Support nor Oppose
I am personally unsure of the benefits and would like to review closely in detail before declaring a position.
Josette Williams
Strongly Support
Fatalities decreased due to other non-policing actions. The Coalition is working to create safer streets, accomplished by city actions: lower transit fares, clear pedestrian crossings, dedicated bike lanes, enhanced technology for speed issues, decreasing police encounters.
Evandro Carvalho
Strongly Support
This is a great way for us to increase employment in District 4 in particular.
Leonard Lee
Strongly Support
It will help to deploy police to other areas where they needed and cut down on overtime.
Troy Smith
Strongly Oppose
Civilian flaggers are not authorized to issue citations as a Police Officers and must drivers would respect the presence of Police Officer at streets-related projects and events.
Josette Williams
Strongly Support
Civilian flaggers were first authorized in 2008. This is a community employment opportunity that would in no way negatively affect safety. Many many states utilize civilian flaggers at lower cost with no resulting effect on safety.
Evandro Carvalho
Somewhat Support
I would be interested in making sure that we put these technologies in the most needed places and make the necessary collection of data as well as adjustments to make sure it is not placed primarily in communities of color.
Leonard Lee
Strongly Support
It will help to monitor speeds and support street safety.
Troy Smith
Neither Support nor Oppose
I would like to review documentation of studies performed in the state of Massachusetts which supports claims of reduce speeding, improve safety and removal of racial bias.
Josette Williams
Strongly Support
Absolutely. See answers above
Evandro Carvalho
Strongly Support
Discussions I have with the neighbors who use these roads such as Blue Hill Avenue, American Legion Hwy, and Washington Street, suggest that we need to do a better and more transparent community process to make sure our residents understand they “why” and have an input in the “how”
Leonard Lee
Strongly Support
Public safety is the utmost priority.
Troy Smith
Somewhat Oppose
Boston is small in passage ways with respect to side streets and some main streets. Reducing lanes and taking away parking creates hardships unfairly to residents and business owners.
Josette Williams
Somewhat Support
In theory I strongly support implementing those measures. However each situation is unique and must be assessed on a case by case basis. The bias should be in favor but a particular location may have unique circumstances.
Evandro Carvalho
Strongly Support
As a state representative in Boston, I participated in this process and this one included a lot of community engagement. Not only should we update it, but we should also go back to the community and discuss the status of what we’ve been able to do so far and get input on how to move forward.
Leonard Lee
Strongly Support
Post pandemic, the plan requires updating.
Troy Smith
Strongly Support
Our City has changed greatly since 2017 and we need to review what are the outcomes of the changes implemented already in order to move forward.
Josette Williams
Somewhat Oppose
This went through an exhaustive process. While any plan must be continually refreshed, considering new conditions and new learning (ex: learning during COVID), an exhaustive review will delay implementation, creating Vision 2035. Keep moving forward with our eyes always open to specific corrections.
Evandro Carvalho
Strongly Support
This again becomes a matter of saving lives, specially in District 4 where there is a disproportionate amount of car crashes. He also helps us with environmental justice by reducing gas, noise, and etc
Leonard Lee
Strongly Support
It will lead to a healthier and safer city, with fewer emissions.
Troy Smith
Neither Support nor Oppose
How does the MBTA plan into the City's Go Boston with respect to providing equitable access through out the City and local Neighborhoods? I do not see the running of buses regularly through out the system and being reliable.
Josette Williams
Strongly Support
Mode shift is an important aspect in terms of air quality, safety and quality of life! However, the reduction in car trips must be linked to quality, frequent service, free or low cost and environmentally sensitive public transit.
Evandro Carvalho
Neither Support nor Oppose
These roads are not in district 4 but MassDot just had a hearing on the redesign of Rutherford Ave last week. I appreciate the community process.
Leonard Lee
Strongly Support
Is this the best use of city, state and federal dollars?
Troy Smith
Strongly Support
The designs and plans may not support the current or future needs projected five or ten years from now. Yes, a reassessment must take place with all major capital projects with close review of the budgets.
Josette Williams
Neither Support nor Oppose
Projects presumably have been through community review, environmental assessment, extensive permitting, often replacing crumbling infrastructure. Need case-by-case assessment, not broad statement.New state law includes procedures for additional review by residents of environment justice communities.
Evandro Carvalho
Strongly Support
In talking to the residents of District 4, I’ve learned that our residents really care about transportation issues such as use of roads, speeding, slow street programs, parking spaces, bike lanes, and curb spaces. Transportation is a key priority for me now.
Leonard Lee
Strongly Support
This will support transit reliability, safety, climate resiliency and livability.
Troy Smith
Strongly Support
Josette Williams
Somewhat Support
Many areas where this work has already taken place, including parts of D4:Blue Hill Ave, Columbia Road. Where no assessment has occurred, I strongly support the effort. We need data-supported plans for set asides for delivery trucks, cycling lanes, clear pedestrian walkways and a green umbrella.
Evandro Carvalho
Neither Support nor Oppose
I can see this for some neighborhoods in the city like back bay or beacon hill. In District 4, many residents struggle to pay bills especially with so many of our essential employees losing their job during the pandemic. At this point I am concerned about adding further financial burden on them.
Leonard Lee
Strongly Support
This will help to support policies related to safe streets, smart streets and climate resiliency
Troy Smith
Strongly Oppose
Why are we taxing annually when an individuals do not poses the Residential Sticker they should be charged a parking violation.
Josette Williams
Somewhat Support
Basically the fee is a regressive tax which will disproportionately affect lower income individuals. Before implementation, there must be a social justice impact analysis. This is the biggest concern for one of my neighbors on Fowler St.
Evandro Carvalho
Strongly Support
Yes, these options can make it more possible for people to live decently if they can save on transportation. It also may lead to getting more jobs as transportation costs would be less of a barrier to taking some jobs.
Leonard Lee
Strongly Support
This will help to reduce disparities in access to transportation.
Troy Smith
Neither Support nor Oppose
It sounds good but a detail review of the operational budget of the MBTA would give a better since of what the MBTA is capable of by creating free bus service and a low-Income fare option.
Josette Williams
Strongly Support
See previous answers
Evandro Carvalho
Strongly Support
Yes. This should help with traffic accidents involving pedestrians.
Leonard Lee
Strongly Support
This will help to promote safe streets for all.
Troy Smith
Strongly Support
Josette Williams
Strongly Support
See previous answers
Evandro Carvalho
Strongly Support
All developments need to include walkability and open space. And also create an Access and Opportunity Committee to make sure the goals of the resident jobs policy on percentages to be hired from people of color, women, Boston residents are met.
Leonard Lee
Strongly Support
Better, healthier livability
Troy Smith
Neither Support nor Oppose
I personally would have to review the project large-scale developments in order to answer appropriately.
Josette Williams
Strongly Support
Economic development+creation of well-paying jobs is essential to residents' well-being. But the health of the city must be defined more broadly, including the creation of greenspace, walkable areas and areas where people play and decompress. Frederick Law Olmstead: "Parks preserve democracy."
Evandro Carvalho
Strongly Support
Yes, we have a huge crisis of high rents and home prices that leaves tenants with terrible choices of stay and pay a huge percentage of their income, never be able to own a home, and/or leave Boston.
So we must take multiple steps leading to more affordable options for buying and renting.
Leonard Lee
Strongly Support
We must respond more effectively to our affordable housing crisis.
Troy Smith
Neither Support nor Oppose
Josette Williams
Strongly Support
Unfortunately we are very far from achieving our goals. Housing must be prioritized if we want to continue to have a diverse, vibrant , livable city where all can thrive. We must increase density, particularly near public transportation.
Evandro Carvalho
Strongly Support
Yes, let's pass and implement that legislation.
Leonard Lee
Strongly Support
We must respond more effectively to our affordable housing crisis.
Troy Smith
Somewhat Oppose
Parking is being swallowed up in the mass development within our City and with an unreliable MBTA system people should have the options to provide their own transportation as need be.
Josette Williams
Somewhat Support
Transportation is essential for lower-income people for job access. We need balance: how close is the development to public transportation? Elimination may result in more on-street parking; this may work in some areas. Makes sense to authorize parking elimination/reduction w/ certain criteria.
Evandro Carvalho
Strongly Support
Leonard Lee
Strongly Support
We must respond more effectively to our affordable housing crisis.
Troy Smith
Strongly Oppose
Josette Williams
Somewhat Support
See above response.Reducing # of parking spaces is not going to make a “luxury” price development into a “moderately” priced development. Current parking requirements should be reviewed as part of the overall review of the Zoning Code and the result may vary by district.
Evandro Carvalho
Strongly Support
Yes, I would engage fellow councilors in meetings with the Mayor and Department heads on getting this done on a set time scale.
Leonard Lee
Strongly Support
We must respond more effectively to our affordable housing crisis.
Troy Smith
Strongly Support
Josette Williams
Strongly Support
It is actually astonishing that these neighborhood plans are not in the Zoning Code, given the effort and community input that has gone into them. Again, a thorough code update is also essential. It has been piecemeal since 1964.
Evandro Carvalho
Strongly Support
Yes, we need to expand this for both project based and mobile vouchers. Earlier I’ve outlined some new sources of revenue for housing and the city recently got over $500 million in federal American Rescue Plan Act funding, some of which could go to this.
Leonard Lee
Strongly Support
We must respond more effectively to our affordable housing crisis and the threat of displacement.
Troy Smith
Neither Support nor Oppose
Josette Williams
Strongly Support
Great program providing housing to more people facing displacement/without housing and builds on the federal Section 8. It is one small step in the reduction of homelessness. Given it is a City funded program, it is subject to budgetary constraints but must be given priority.